Introduction

In recent years, the landscape of healthcare data exchange has become a focal point of policy, technology, and ethical debates. Central to these discussions is information blocking, defined broadly as practices that interfere with the access, exchange, or use of electronic health information (EHI), even when such practices are not explicitly prohibited by law.

While the federal government, particularly through the 21st Century Cures Act and the ONC (Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology), has taken steps to combat information blocking, perceptions among hospital leaders remain complex and evolving. Understanding these perceptions is crucial because hospital leadership influences policies, resource allocation, and organizational culture—factors that ultimately determine how effectively health data is shared.

This article offers updated insights into hospital leaders’ perceptions of information blocking, examining recent surveys, qualitative studies, and expert commentary. It explores the motivations, barriers, and attitudes of hospital executives regarding data sharing, alongside the implications for patient care, innovation, and health equity.

---

1. Defining Information Blocking in the Healthcare Context

What Is Information Blocking?

The ONC, as part of the Cures Act Final Rule, defines information blocking as practices that:

• Are likely to interfere with the access, exchange, or use of EHI.
• Are done intentionally or unintentionally.
• Lack a valid justification under specific exemptions.

Practices deemed as information blocking include:

• Restricting access to or use of electronic health information.
• Imposing unreasonable or discriminatory policies.
• Charging excessive fees for data sharing.
• Limiting data interoperability through technical or contractual barriers.

Why Is It a Concern?

• Patient-Centered Care: Limited data sharing hampers coordinated care.
• Research & Innovation: Data silos inhibit medical research.
• Health Equity: Disparate data access can worsen health disparities.
• Policy Enforcement: The government aims to promote transparency and competition.

---

2. Evolving Regulatory Landscape and Its Impact on Perceptions

The 21st Century Cures Act and ONC Rules

The Cures Act, enacted in 2016, mandated the elimination of information blocking practices. The ONC’s Final Rule, effective from 2021, established compliance requirements, penalties, and transparency mechanisms.

Perceptions of Hospital Leaders in Response to Regulations

Recent surveys indicate that:

• Many hospital leaders are aware of the regulations but vary in understanding the scope.
• Concerns about compliance costs and operational disruptions persist.
• Some leaders perceive the regulations as beneficial for patient engagement and market competitiveness.
• Others view them as potential threats to existing business models, especially regarding proprietary EHR systems.

Impact of Policy Changes on Attitudes

• Increased transparency and accountability measures have shifted perceptions.
• Hospitals are investing in interoperability solutions, but challenges remain.
• Some leaders express skepticism about the enforceability of regulations and the potential for unintended consequences.

---

3. Current Perceptions of Hospital Leaders on Information Blocking

Key Themes from Recent Studies

a) Awareness and Knowledge Gaps

While most hospital executives acknowledge the importance of data sharing, awareness of specific legal definitions and obligations remains inconsistent.

• A 2022 survey by the Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society (HIMSS) found that approximately 70% of hospital leaders were aware of the Cures Act provisions, but only 45% understood the detailed regulatory requirements.
• Many perceive information blocking as a systemic issue driven by entrenched organizational and technical barriers rather than malicious intent.

b) Motivations Behind Information Blocking

Hospital leaders’ perceptions of why data sharing is restricted include:

• Financial Incentives: Protecting proprietary EHR data to maintain market dominance.
• Operational Concerns: Fear of data breaches, liability, or increased workload.
• Technical Challenges: Lack of standardized formats and interoperability infrastructure.
• Legal and Contractual Barriers: Vendor restrictions and existing data use agreements.

Perception of Malicious Intent

Most hospital leaders do not view information blocking as inherently malicious but see it as a consequence of complex systems, legacy infrastructure, and market competition.

c) Barriers to Data Sharing

• Technical Limitations: Compatibility issues, lack of standardized APIs, and data quality concerns.
• Financial Concerns: Costs associated with data extraction, formatting, and security.
• Legal Risks: Fear of liability from sharing sensitive data improperly.
• Organizational Culture: Resistance to change, lack of incentives, or internal policies that discourage sharing.
• Vendor Constraints: Proprietary systems or contractual restrictions imposed by vendors.

d) Perceived Benefits of Data Sharing

Hospital leaders increasingly recognize that sharing data can:

• Improve patient outcomes through care coordination.
• Enhance hospital reputation and patient trust.
• Facilitate research and quality improvement initiatives.
• Meet regulatory and accreditation standards.

e) Concerns and Risks

However, leaders also express concerns about:

• Data security and privacy breaches.
• Loss of competitive advantage.
• Increased administrative burden.
• Potential legal liabilities.

Attitudes Toward Enforcement and Penalties

• Many hospital leaders support transparency measures such as public reporting of compliance.
• Opinions vary on penalties; some fear disproportionate sanctions could harm organizational reputation or finances.
• There is a general consensus that enforcement should be balanced with support for technical and operational capacity building.

---

4. Organizational Factors Influencing Perceptions

Leadership Commitment

• Hospital leadership’s understanding and commitment to interoperability significantly influence organizational culture.
• Leaders with a strategic focus on innovation tend to view data sharing positively.

Resources and Infrastructure

• Investment in modern EHR systems and APIs correlates with more favorable perceptions.
• Smaller or resource-constrained hospitals report greater difficulty in complying with regulations.

Vendor Relationships

• Dependence on proprietary systems can create perceptions of systemic barriers.
• Hospitals with flexible vendor contracts and open architectures tend to perceive fewer obstacles.

Internal Policies and Incentives

• Incentivizing data sharing through internal policies encourages positive perceptions.
• Conversely, fear of operational disruptions fosters resistance.

---

5. Implications for Patient Care and Health System Performance

Improved Outcomes Through Data Sharing

Hospital leaders increasingly see the potential for better patient outcomes via:

• Reduced duplicate testing.
• Faster diagnoses.
• Coordinated care delivery.

Challenges in Implementation

Perceptions of technical complexity and costs create hurdles:

• Slow adoption of interoperability standards.
• Fragmented data ecosystems.
• Variability in data quality.

Impact on Disparities and Equity

Leaders recognize that equitable data sharing can:

• Improve access for underserved populations.
• Enable targeted interventions.
• Reduce disparities in care.

However, concerns about technological inequities persist.

---

6. Future Directions and Evolving Perceptions

Growing Emphasis on Value-Based Care

As healthcare shifts toward value-based models, hospital leaders’ perceptions increasingly favor interoperability as a means to improve efficiency and outcomes.

Technological Innovations

Advances in APIs, FHIR (Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources), and AI-driven data analytics are viewed positively but also raise concerns about data privacy and security.

Policy and Incentive Alignment

Leaders expect ongoing regulatory clarity and incentives to foster a culture of open data sharing.

Ethical and Cultural Shifts

There’s a rising recognition of data sharing as an ethical obligation to improve patient care and system-wide health.

Perceived Risks and Opportunities

While some leaders remain cautious about operational risks, many see data sharing as an opportunity to innovate and differentiate their organizations.

---

7. Challenges and Opportunities for Stakeholders

For Policymakers

• Need to emphasize support and resources for compliance.
• Clarify regulations to reduce ambiguity.
• Promote best practices and standards.

For Vendors

• Develop open, standards-based systems.
• Remove contractual barriers to interoperability.

For Hospital Leaders

• Invest in infrastructure and training.
• Cultivate organizational culture supportive of data sharing.
• Engage with patients on data privacy and rights.

For Patients

• Increased transparency and access.
• Improved care coordination.
• Greater trust in healthcare systems.

---

8. Conclusions

Summary of Key Insights

• Hospital leaders generally recognize the importance of data sharing but face real and perceived barriers.
• The perception of information blocking is evolving, with many leaders viewing it as a systemic issue rather than malicious intent.
• Technical, financial, organizational, and vendor-related factors influence perceptions.
• There is a growing acknowledgment of the benefits of interoperability for patient care, research, and health equity.
• Concerns about security, liability, and operational disruption remain but are increasingly balanced by recognition of the strategic value.

Moving Forward

• Continued education and clarity around regulations are vital.
• Investment in technology and organizational culture change are critical.
• Collaboration among policymakers, vendors, providers, and patients will shape future perceptions.

---

References

• ONC. (2020). 21st Century Cures Act: Interoperability, Information Blocking, and the ONC Health IT Certification Program.
• HIMSS. (2022). Survey on Hospital Leadership Perceptions of Data Sharing and Interoperability.
• Health Affairs. (2023). Evolving Perspectives on Healthcare Data Sharing.
• Various peer-reviewed articles and industry reports.